An NSW Lot Owner questions whether a bylaws is required for BBQs on apartment balconies. Leanne Habib of Premium Strata and Tyrone Shandiman of Strata Insurance Solutions have provided the following response.
Question: Should we have a bylaw allowing residents to have a BBQ on their apartment balcony? If we have no bylaw and a BBQ becomes a fire hazard, will the Strata Committee Members be held liable?
Should the Owners Corporation pass a By-Law, if they don’t already have one, in context to allowing a tenant or owner occupier to have a BBQ on their apartment balcony?
I understand that the NSW Department of Fair Trading on their website claims that its fine for occupiers in an apartment to have a BBQ cooker on their balcony but it’s silent when it comes to mentioning about having a By-Law.
However, in an article that was published on 5 July 2018 by Eric Hahn – General Manager of Elgas – ‘Balcony BBQ – Using a Gas BBQ on a Balcony Unit’ a much more cautious approach ought to be taken by an occupier which includes amongst other things; checking to see if the Strata Complex has a By-Law in allowing a BBQ cooker on the Lot’s balcony.
I’ve also received information from a Strata Insurance Broker who stated that pursuant to statutory disclosure requirements of the Insurance Contracts legislation, it’s necessary that the Owners Corporation inform their insurer of BBQ’s that occupiers have on their balcony. This Broker also stated that the premiums will increase because of the potential hazardous risk of BBQs (especially those fitted with LPG bottles) pose. In addition, failing to notify the Insurer of occupiers in a Strata Complex using a BBQ will compromise the existing Owners Corporation’s Insurance Policy.
I’ve raised this with our strata committee and some members believe a By-Law is unnecessary and they are unconcerned about reporting BBQ’s on lot balconies to our Insurer. I feel they are ignoring that this matter should be addressed at an Owners Corporation meeting and not a matter that is addressed exclusively by the Strata Committee.
I feel these members have failed to consider those individuals with an acute sensitive adverse reaction to smells which is a recognised medical ailment and these smells include cigarette/tobacco smoke and cooking odours from a BBQ.
Can the Strata Committee be effectively sued by a Lot Owner or Lot Owners pursuant to s.37 Strata Management Act (NSW) 2015, for failing to act with due diligence in not having this matter addressed at an Owners Corporation Meeting such as EGM or AGM?
And still on s.37 of the aforesaid Act, if a BBQ cooker becomes a fire hazard as explained in the article by Eric Hahn, will the Strata Committee Members be held liable to pay for any damage caused because of the failure to disclose to the Insurer occupiers having BBQs on their apartment balconies?
Answer: You need to check what your contract states with regard to strata manager insurance commissions.
Leanne Habib: We have never heard of there being a positive duty to inform an owners corporation’s insurer of the presence of BBQs at the scheme and we can not see that the presence of BBQs is inherently more dangerous than gas cooktops or heaters. The owners corporation has a duty to notify an insurer of risks, however, in our view, BBQ use is quite standard and widespread.
That said, many schemes do have a by-law regulating (sometimes prohibiting) the use of portable BBQs on the balcony for safety and smoke drift purposes.
You should contact your insurer and confirm the specifics for your strata scheme and propose the implementation of a by-law to regulate safe use of BBQs and smoke drift regulation.
As to whether the strata committee may be sued in case of a BBQ accident, Section 260 of the Act provides protection from personal liability for members of the strata committee who act in good faith.
Tyrone Shandiman: From an insurance perspective, notifying an insurer of the presence of BBQs on lot owner balconies is not something we have ever been requested to provide.
Should the insurer seek to deny cover for failure to disclose the presence of BBQs on apartment balconies the body corporate may have protection under Section 21 of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 which states:
(2) Your duty however, does not require disclosure of any matter:
(c) that the insurer knows or in the ordinary course of the insurer’s business as an insurer ought to know.
The Owners corporation will have good reason to suggest that the use of BBQs on apartment balconies should be a matter the insurer ought to know in the ordinary course of their business.
Whether or not the committee can be sued is a matter for the solicitors and the courts to decide at the time of a claim looking at the facts of the case.
None-the-less office bearers may be covered by Office Bearers Liability insurance (if it is taken out in the policy) should legal action be brought for their actions as an office bearer.
This post appears in Strata News #235.
- NSW: Q&A Can We Avoid Strata Manager Insurance Commissions?
- NSW: Q&A Smoke drift from tenant who regularly has a smoke on the balcony above
- NSW ByLaw Review. How / Where do we register our new bylaws?
- NSW: Q&A What does public liability insurance include?
This article is not intended to be personal advice and you should not rely on it as a substitute for any form of advice.
Have a question about BBQs on apartment balconies or something to add to the article? Leave a comment below.