This article concerning the right to own a companion animal in a no pet building has been replied to by Leanne Habib, Premium Strata.
Question: There are a number of very vocal apartment owners in my building who are against animals of any type, including a companion animal.
GET THE LATEST STRATA NEWS / ARTICLES DIRECT TO YOUR INBOX HERE
I am hoping you may be able to give me some advice regarding the Bylaw that has been registered at my newly built apartment complex concerning pets.
The development was initially sold off the plan from 2014 and completed earlier this year. The sales agents were told it was pet-friendly but when we went to sign the contract, the developer had made an error and put in an old No Pets Bylaw. Even though only a very small number of apartments had been sold at that time, he advised that it was too hard to change and to wait until the development was completed and then the owners could change the bylaws.
Unfortunately, there are a number of very vocal apartment owners who are against having animals of any type in the building, including a companion animal.
A number of owners moved in with their animals anyway .. in breach of the bylaw.
I have a dog but decided to wait until we changed the bylaw to move in. However, 6 months down the track and my attempts have not been successful.
A couple of owners on the committee think it is their duty to enforce the bylaws by intimidating owners that have brought their dog or cat to live with them. It has become very a divided and acrimonious community.
Only 1 of the 9 committee members wants pets so they have voted to send out notices reminding everyone to abide by the bylaws..
As I can’t move in with my dog, I tried to sell the apartment. I have had multiple buyers pull out when they found out it wasn’t pet-friendly. So now I can’t move in and I can’t sell it.
We have unwell residents that have been warned about their cats. One unwell resident is accosted by the strata committee member everytime they are out with their dog.
I myself have chronic health issues that can leave me housebound for weeks. My dog is my companion aminal.
The stress of fighting for my companion animal is affecting me physically, emotionally and financially.
Answer: If you can demonstrate your animal meets the requirements of a companion animal for the specific outlined range of disabilities, the Owners Corporation cannot prohibit the keeping of your animal.
Section 139 of the new legislation clearly states that no by-law may prevent the keeping of an “assistance” animal.
(5) By-law cannot prevent keeping of assistance animal A by-law has no force or effect to the extent to which it purports to prohibit or restrict the keeping on a lot of an assistance animal (as referred to in section 9 of the Disability Discrimination Act 1992 of the Commonwealth) used by an owner or occupier of the lot as an assistance animal or the use of an assistance animal for that purpose by a person on a lot or common property.
Note that the alleged assistance animal must comply with the requirements of the Disability Discrimination Act.
If you can demonstrate your animal meets those requirements and you qualify for the specific outlined range of disabilities, the Owners Corporation cannot prohibit the keeping of your animal.
Provided you and your animal qualify, you may take your complaints to the Australian Human Rights Commission.
This post appears in Strata News #203.
Leanne Habib
Premium Strata
P: 02 9281 6440
E: [email protected]
You can connect with Leanne & Premium Strata on Facebook, Twitter & LinkedIn.
This article is not intended to be personal advice and you should not rely on it as a substitute for any form of advice.
NSW: Keeping The Dog: strata committee can’t outlaw a companion animal
Bailey Compton, Leverage Group – Solicitors & Academy | August 2017 – Leverage acted for a person whose dog was rejected by the strata committee. But the puppy is still there. Our client lived in a no dog building. The by-laws made a ruling that no dogs were permitted. NCAT ordered the dog to go.
Well, the dog was nothing special! I thought he was cute, but in real terms, he was just a dog and the strata committee hated him. But, this dog came with a purpose.
Leverage’s client was a single parent. The circumstances that surrounded the separation of the parents had affected the child greatly. In fact, it has put the kid into counselling. The counsellor suggested that a pet may operate to save the kid’s emotions.
This was put to the strata committee. They had some sympathy but they still didn’t like the dog. It was just a pug! A nice little dog that never barked, but acted as a comfort blanket for the nine-year-old girl.
Never fear, there is always a way around such a problem. In the Disability Discrimination Act 1992, a strata committee cannot outlaw a companion dog, like a guide dog. The Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 states that a strata scheme cannot outlaw a companion animal.
Download our FREE Ebook – NSW Pets in Apartments: What are the rules?
The solution was easy: we got the dog trained as a companion animal and had it registered with the local council. The strata scheme was not happy, but their powers to evict the dog were now excluded.
We kept the dog and protected the child’s mental health. As a side point, a compassionate strata committee would have found a way to resolve this issue. The psychological condition was real, there was no evidence that the dog affected anyone on common property and there was a real need for the animal. Surely sensible people could have found a solution without Leverage needing to create one.
This post appears in Strata News #155.
Read next:
Bailey Compton, Leverage Group – Solicitors & Academy.
This article was published with the permission of the author and first appeared on Leverage Academy Website.
For more information about companion dogs or strata information particular to NSW, visit our Strata Pets Living in Apartments orNSW Strata Legislation
After a free PDF of this article? Log into your existing LookUpStrata Account to download the printable file. Not a member? Simple – join for free on our Registration page.
In Victoria:
Companion dogs are allowed irrespective of by-laws. The owners could be in breach of discrimination law (anywhere in Australia), regardless of the legal advice received.
If there is to be a by-law of any sort about animals, it should simply state that owners should ensure that their pets do not make excessive noise, pose a threat to children (or any other resident) and if the owners corporation is subjected to any liability exposure as a result of the actions of an animal, the OC can make a claim against the pet owner.
Of course if the pet poses a nuisance, the owners corporation is well within their right to serve a notice that the owner must remove the animal, stating the reasons.
(Though this rule would not apply to companion dogs)
Hi Ivc
Thanks for your comment. You may also be interested in our Pets in Owners Corporations in Victoria article.
Hi lvc
We have received the following comment from Leanne Habib, Premium Strata:
In NSW there appears to be a clear distinction between a “companion animal” registered with a local council and an “assistance animal” referred to Section 9 of the Disability Discrimination Act, 1992 of the Commonwealth (the latter being protected under the new strata legislation and broader than hearing/seeing dogs and to assist persons with disabilities).
Hi Nikki,
If the dogs were there before the bylaws were either changed or strengthen, would not the matter of dogs residing be governed by previous/original bylaw?
Regards Linda
Hi Linda
We have received the following comment back from Leanne Habib, Premium Strata:
If the dogs were there (and approved at that time), the approval would likely have been given for the life of that particular animal subject to compliance with any relevant by-laws pertaining to cleaning up after the dog etc and the laws applicable at that time. Normally, strata schemes which change their stance on the keeping of animals, exempt previously approved animals for the term of their lives and usually, unless the animals misbehave/soil/are noisy/otherwise in breach, owners corporation’s do not withdraw approval for previously approved animals.
Hi there,
thanks for this article. Unfortunately there still remain very unreasonable people in management committees in strata units. Instead of taking route of allowing pets under certain guidelines, our committee are having a lawyer who lives on the premises draft a bylaw which will state that no animals will be allowed under any circumstances (apart from guide dog or companion animals for special needs. I’m wondering if there is any way to dissuade from such a move which seems very unfair and means that owners who already have dogs would have to move or have their pets removed. Thanks for your time. regards Julie
Hi Julie
Thanks for the comments. If you are located in NSW, you may wish to read this article by Allison Benson, Kerin Benson Lawyers regarding unreasonable bylaws: NSW By-Laws & Pets: What is harsh unconscionable or oppressive?
Let me know if you have any further questions and all the best with the situation.
Nikki