Enter your email Address

LookUpStrata

Strata Information Leading to Open Discussion

advert Lannock strata finance
Australia's Top Property Blog Dedicated to Strata Living
  • Home
  • What is strata?
    • Strata Legislation – Rules and ByLaws
    • What is Strata?
    • Glossary of NSW Strata Terms and Jargon
    • Understand Strata Management with this Five-Minute Guide
    • Cracking the Strata Fees Code
    • Strata Finance
  • Strata Topics
    • Strata Information By State
      • New South Wales
      • Queensland
      • Victoria
      • Australian Capital Territory
      • South Australia
      • Tasmania
      • Western Australia
      • Northern Territory
    • Strata Information By Topic
      • By-Laws & Legislation
      • Smoking
      • Parking
      • Noise & Neighbours
      • Insurance
      • Pets
      • Your Levies
      • New Law Reform
      • Maintenance & Common Property
      • Committee Concerns
      • NBN & Telecommunications
      • Building Defects
      • Renting / Selling / Buying Property
      • Strata Managers
      • Building Managers & Caretakers
      • Strata Plan / Strata Inspection Report
      • Apartment Living Sustainability
    • Strata Webinars
      • NSW Strata Webinars
      • QLD Strata Webinars
      • VIC Strata Webinars
      • ACT Strata Webinars
      • SA Strata Webinars
      • WA Strata Webinars
    • Upcoming and FREE Strata Events
  • Blog
    • Newsletter Archives
  • The Strata Magazine
    • The NSW Strata Magazine
    • The QLD Strata Magazine
    • The VIC Strata Magazine
    • The WA Strata Magazine
  • Site Sponsors
  • About Us
    • Testimonials for LookUpStrata
  • Help
    • Ask A Strata Question
    • Q&As – about the LookUpStrata site
    • Sitemap
Home » Defects » Defects QLD » QLD: Enderley Gardens [2024] QBCCMCmr 60

QLD: Enderley Gardens [2024] QBCCMCmr 60

Published April 3, 2024 By The LookUpStrata Team 3 Comments Last Updated August 5, 2024

Share with your strata community

  • Share
  • LinkedIn
  • Email

This article is about maintenance obligations and reimbursement for damages has been supplied by the Commissioner for Body Corporate and Community Management.

This case examines the jurisdiction and powers of adjudicators and whether a body corporate is responsible for damage to property, or other costs, caused by defects in original elements of the building that a body corporate has a duty to maintain.

Background

This dispute arose because of defects in the construction of a concrete suspended flooring system that formed the first floor of the scheme’s building. The defects were likely there from when the building was built, but only came to light after movement in the floor of the applicant’s bathroom caused tiles to crack and the waterproofing to fail. The applicant said the body corporate had a duty to maintain the floor in structurally sound condition and its failure to do so had caused damage to his property.

The applicant was seeking to be reimbursed more than the $10,000 limit an adjudicator could award for damage to property caused by a body corporate’s failure to maintain (Section 281(2)(b) of the Act). He also wanted to be compensated for lost rent, which he said was beyond an adjudicator’s power to order. For these reasons, he asked the adjudicator to dismiss the application so all of his claims for damages could be dealt with in at one time in another court or tribunal of competent jurisdiction.

However, the adjudicator declined to dismiss the application for it to be heard elsewhere. The adjudicator found the primary issue in dispute was whether the body corporate had breached a duty to maintain the floor. She was thus satisfied the dispute was about the performance of duties under the Act and a claimed contravention of the Act and was therefore within an adjudicator’s jurisdiction. Although some of the orders sought by the lot owner might be beyond the powers of an adjudicator, that could only be assessed once a finding had been made on the primary issue in dispute.

The applicant explained that in 2015, it was thought his bathroom was the source of water leaks into the lot next to his. The applicant says he paid a body corporate insurance excess relating to claims for damages to the neighbouring lot. He then renovated his bathroom, including re-waterproofing and re-tiling the area. However, in 2017 his tenants reported another water leak, this time, within his own lot. He says his lot became uninhabitable and the tenants vacated it in or around October 2017.

This started a lengthy dispute between the applicant and the body corporate about the cause of the leak and the resulting damage. Both parties obtained several engineering reports to discover the source of the issue. In summary, it was discovered that at the time the building was constructed, a ‘control joint’ – which is intended to move – had erroneously been placed in the floor of the lot and through the bathroom. There were also questions raised whether the floor was properly supported from underneath. The engineering reports recommended certain works be carried out to brace the joint and limit the movement at the joint.

The applicant and body corporate could not agree on which party was responsible for the costs of repairing the bathroom and the costs of consequential works to the kitchen. In the meantime, the lot remained untenanted between 2017 and 2020. In 2020, the applicant completed further renovation works to make the lot habitable again. The parties could also not agree on whether additional investigation or works to the floor were required.

The applicant sought orders that the body corporate:

  1. reimburse him for the insurance excesses he paid and his first bathroom renovations relating to the 2015 leak;
  2. reimburse him for the reports he obtained to ascertain the cause of the damage;
  3. reimburse him for the works to his kitchen and bathroom caused by the 2017 leak; and
  4. obtain a further engineering report and take all reasonable steps to execute rectification works in accordance with that report.

CLICK HERE TO BE NOTIFIED WHEN WE PUBLISH CONTENT TO THE SITE

Decision

The adjudicator was satisfied that the body corporate had a duty to maintain the floor in a structurally sound condition and that it had breached that duty.

She said that given the credible evidence that the defects in the floor may not have been sufficiently remediated, she made orders for the body corporate to engage a structural engineer to provide a further report.

She also made orders pursuant to section 281 of the Act that the body corporate reimburse the applicant for some of the more recent repairs he had carried out to his bathroom. The adjudicator also made an order pursuant to section 276(1) that the body corporate reimburse the lot owner for some works to his kitchen that were necessitated by the repairs to the floor. A further order was made that the body corporate reimburse the applicant the cost of one, but not all, of the engineering reports.

Information Service Freecall 1800 060 119
Commissioner for Body Corporate and Community Management

This post appears in Strata News #689.

Have a question about maintenance obligations and reimbursement for damages or something to add to the article? Leave a comment below.

Read next:

  • QLD: Maintenance versus improvements
  • QLD: Debt disputes – a case study

This article has been republished with permission from the author and first appeared on the UOAQ website.

Visit Strata By-Laws and Legislation, Maintenance and Common Property OR Strata Legislation Queensland

Looking for strata information concerning your state? For state-specific strata information, try here.

After a free PDF of this article? Log into your existing LookUpStrata Account to download the printable file. Not a member? Simple – join for free on our Registration page.

Share with your strata community

  • Share
  • LinkedIn
  • Email

Comments

  1. Tom Sharwood says

    April 9, 2024 at 8:32 am

    Strata committee members should be required to read these items as most are illiterate when it comes to Strata regulations and responsibilities.
    I have to have a licence to manage a building (with a trust account) but these elected representatives of the owners (sometimes 110+) control hundreds of thousands of dollars of other peoples’ money.

    Reply
    • Gardner says

      April 9, 2024 at 11:18 am

      There is strata manager to assist the committee, they might equiped with knowledge.

      Reply
    • Chris Irons says

      April 9, 2024 at 4:05 pm

      I agree with you and for the reasons you have articulated. I have advocated for some time for training for committees to be mandatory, especially given there is already an excellent (and free) online training course provided by BCCM. Being responsible for such significant decisions should require more than the raising of one’s hand to nominate for the committee.

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search For Strata Articles

  • Advert Stratabox
  • StrataBox Advert
Subscribe Newsletter

TESTIMONIALS

"LookUpStrata should be compulsory reading for every member of a Body Corporate Committee. It provides the most understandable answers to all the common (and uncommon) questions that vex Body Corporates everywhere. Too often Committee members do not understand what Body Corporates are legally able to do and not do. LookUpStrata helps educate everybody living in a Body Corporate environment for free." John, Lot Owner

"It's the best and most professional body corporate information source a strata manager could have! Thanks to the whole team!" MQ, Strata Manager

"I like reading all the relevant articles on important issues on Strata living that the LookUpStrata Newsletter always effectively successfully covers"
Carole, Lot Owner

"Strata is so confusing and your newsletters and website are my go-to to get my questions answered. It has helped me out so many times and is a fabulous knowledge hub." Izzy, Lot Owner

Quick Login

Log In
Register Lost Password

Categories

  • Contact a Strata Specialist on the LookUpStrata Directory
  • Ask Us A Strata Question
  • New South Wales
  • Queensland
  • Victoria
  • Australian Capital Territory
  • South Australia
  • Tasmania
  • Western Australia
  • Northern Territory
  • ByLaws & Legislation
  • Smoking
  • Parking
  • Noise & Neighbours
  • Insurance
  • Pets
  • Levies
  • Law Reform
  • Maintenance & Common Property
  • Committee Concerns
  • NBN & Telecommunications
  • Building Defects
  • Renting / Selling / Buying
  • Strata Managers
  • Building Managers and Caretakers
  • Strata Reports / Plans
  • Sustainability

Recent Comments

  • Irene smith on QLD: Q&A Who Can Access Common Property?
  • Fris on QLD: Q&As Keys, fobs, swipe cards, security access and issues
  • Nikki Jovicic on VIC: Expert Panel To Review Owners Corporation Laws
  • Nikki Jovicic on QLD: Removing a terrible Caretaker – Terminating Management Rights. VIDEO
  • Josephine Tedesco on VIC: Expert Panel To Review Owners Corporation Laws
  • Auriel June on NAT: Understanding concrete cancer in strata buildings
  • Pauline Saunders on WA: Strata Manager Qualification Requirements Changes and Compliance
  • Barry Beveridge on QLD: Removing a terrible Caretaker – Terminating Management Rights. VIDEO
  • Barry Ewing on QLD: Owner Improvements
  • Josephine Tedesco on VIC: Expert Panel To Review Owners Corporation Laws

WEBSITE INFORMATION

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions of Use
  • Terms of Use for Comments and Community Discussion
  • Advertising Disclosure
  • Sitemap

ASK A STRATA QUESTION

You’ve Found Strata Help!

Ask a strata, owners corporation or body corporate question and we will do our best to source a useful response from our network of strata professionals around Australia. Submit your question here.

Disclaimer

The opinions and/or views expressed on the LookUpStrata site, including, but not limited to, our blogs and comments, represent the thoughts of individual bloggers and our online communities, and not those necessarily of LookUpStrata Pty Ltd. In all instances, information should not be taken as advice and independent legal advice should be consulted.

CONTACT US VIA EMAIL

Copyright © 2025 · LookUpStrata ® Pty Ltd · All rights reserved