Enter your email Address

  • Home
  • What is strata?
    • Strata Legislation
    • What is Strata?
    • A Glossary of NSW Strata Terms and Jargon
    • Strata Property Basics: Strata Owners Corporation
    • Strata 101: Strata title
    • Understand Strata Management with this Five-Minute Guide
    • Cracking the Strata Fees Code
    • Strata Finance
    • 2021 Updated Guide: Master the Art of Strata Insurance
  • Strata Topics
    • Strata Information By State
      • New South Wales
      • Queensland
      • Victoria
      • Australian Capital Territory
      • South Australia
      • Tasmania
      • Western Australia
      • Northern Territory
    • Strata Information By Topic
      • COVID-19
      • By-Laws & Legislation
      • Smoking
      • Parking
      • Noise & Neighbours
      • Insurance
      • Pets
      • Your Levies
      • New Law Reform
      • Maintenance & Common Property
      • Committee Concerns
      • NBN & Telecommunications
      • Building Defects
      • Renting / Selling / Buying Property
      • Strata Managers
      • Building Managers & Caretakers
      • Strata Plan / Strata Inspection Report
      • Apartment Living Sustainability
  • Blog
    • Newsletter Archives
  • The Strata Magazine
    • The NSW Strata Magazine
    • The QLD Strata Magazine
    • The VIC Strata Magazine
    • The WA Strata Magazine
  • Advertise With Us
    • Site Sponsors
    • LookUpStrata Site Advertising
    • Your Own Branded Newsletter
  • About Us
    • Testimonials for LookUpStrata
  • Help
    • Ask A Strata Question
    • Q&As – about the LookUpStrata site
    • Sitemap

LookUpStrata

Australia's Strata Title Information Site

Whitbread Insurance Brokers
Australia's Top Property Blog Dedicated to Strata Living
You are here: Home / Maintenance & Common Property / Maintenance NSW / NSW: Damages claim for failed common property? Don’t take it to the Tribunal!

NSW: Damages claim for failed common property? Don’t take it to the Tribunal!

Published January 21, 2020 By Samantha Saw, Speirs Ryan Leave a Comment Last Updated January 23, 2020

Sharing is caring!

6shares

This article discussing damages claim for failed common property in NSW strata has been provided by Samantha Saw, Speirs Ryan.

The recent joint decision in The Owners – Strata Plan No 74835 v Pullicin; The Owners – Strata Plan No 80412 v Vickery [2020] NSWCATAP 5 (‘Pullicin and Vickery’) has clarified that the New South Wales Civil and Administrative Tribunal (‘NCAT’) does not have the power to award damages for a breach of s 106(1) of the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 (NSW)(‘SSMA’), being the obligation on an owners corporation to repair and maintain common property.

GET NOTIFIED WHEN WE PUBLISH NEW Q&As, NEWS AND ARTICLES TO THE SITE

In both cases, the lot owners experienced water penetration and subsequent damage to their apartments from failed common property, and applied to NCAT for orders seeking damages including for loss of rent as provided for under s 106(5) of the SSMA.

failed common property Section 106 (5) grants a lot owner the right to recover from the owners corporation damages for foreseeable loss as a result of a breach of the duty. Section 232(1)(a) gives NCAT the power to “make an order to settle a complaint or dispute about …the operation, administration or management of a strata scheme under this Act” while s 232(1)(e) gives NCAT the power to “make an order to settle a complaint or dispute about…an exercise of, or failure to exercise, a function conferred or imposed by or under this Act or the by-laws of a strata scheme”.

The lot owners argued that sections 232(1)(a) and (e) grant NCAT the power to award damages for breach of section 106(1) but the Appeal Panel found that neither section 106 or section 232 grant NCAT the power to order damages or compensation.

This significant decision, made by a three-member Appeal Panel including the President and Deputy President of NCAT comes after a number of contradictory decisions on this issue, including The Owners Strata Plan No 30621 v Shum [2018] NSWCATAP 15, where the Appeal Panel ruled NCAT had an unfettered jurisdiction to award damages, and Shih v The Owners— Strata Plan No 87879 [2019] NSWCATAP 263 (‘Shih’), where the Appeal Panel ruled NCAT did not have the power to award damages but held they may have the power to make some kind of ‘compensation’ order.

Pullicin and Vickery has clarified once and for all that damages claims cannot be made through NCAT and the Tribunal has no power to make the compensation orders proposed by the decision in Shih. Claims for damages under section 106 must only be brought before a court of competent jurisdiction (Local, District or Supreme Court of NSW).

Advert NSW Mag Banner

This decision may seem to dilute the intended streamlined process that NCAT is supposed to provide as a ‘one stop shop’ for NSW strata disputes. But on a positive note, any damages claims for breach of section 106(1) will now need to be supported by detailed evidence that complies with the court rules, noting NCAT is not bound by the rules of evidence in this division.

There are a number of issues that arise in relation to applications for failed common property and the timing and scope of proceedings run in contemporaneous divisions, such as seeking an order that the common property is repaired in NCAT and then also bringing proceedings in a separate jurisdiction such as the Local Court for a damages claim.

This decision highlights the need for specialised legal advice in matters concerning disputes of this nature in strata schemes. Speirs Ryan is a Sydney based boutique property law firm with national coverage. The firm is uniquely placed with specialist teams in both strata law and property transactions that enables us to achieve successful outcomes for lot owners and owners corporations both within and beyond strata.

For further information or advice please contact us.

Have a question about damages claim for failed common property? Leave a comment below.

Embed

Read next:

  • NSW: Claiming Consequential Damages Against an Owners Corporation: An Update Post Shih
  • NSW: Confusion Reigns: NCAT Weighs in on its Power to Award Compensation

This post appears in Strata News #313

Samantha Saw
Speirs Ryan
E. [email protected]
P: 02 9248 3414

Disclaimer: The information contained in this article is provided as personal information only. It is not intended to be legal advice and it should not be used as legal or professional advice. The information in this article should be relied upon – lot owners and owners corporations should seek legal advice for their specific circumstances.

Visit our Maintenance and Common Property OR NSW Strata Legislation

After a free PDF of this article? Log into your existing LookUpStrata Account to download the printable file. Not a member? Simple – join for free on our Registration page.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search For Strata Articles

  • Advert Stratabox
  • StrataBox Advert
  • Advert: StrataLoans
  • Advert: StrataLoans
  • Advert: StrataLoans
Subscribe Newsletter

TESTIMONIAL

"The newsletter is very helpful and gives great guidance with commonly asked questions." Gayle, Lot Owner – November 2020
"I love your regular emails and now this fantastic magazine! Keep up the great work. " David, Lot Owner – August 2020

Quick Login

Log In
Register Lost Password

Categories

  • COVID-19
  • Ask A Strata Question
  • New South Wales
  • Queensland
  • Victoria
  • Australian Capital Territory
  • South Australia
  • Tasmania
  • Western Australia
  • Northern Territory
  • ByLaws & Legislation
  • Smoking
  • Parking
  • Noise & Neighbours
  • Insurance
  • Pets
  • Levies
  • Law Reform
  • Maintenance & Common Property
  • Committee Concerns
  • NBN & Telecommunications
  • Building Defects
  • Renting / Selling / Buying
  • Strata Managers
  • Building Managers and Caretakers
  • Strata Reports / Plans
  • Sustainability

Recent Comments

  • Josephine Wiseman on NSW: Q&A Keeping Pets in a Strata Building
  • martine on QLD: Q&A Holding Positions on the Executive and Ordinary Committee
  • Anna Falk on NSW: Q&A Positions on the Strata Committee
  • Melissa Field on NSW: Annual Window Safety Compliance Reinspection – Minimising the Risk of Non-Compliance
  • Liza Admin on NSW: Q&A Smoke Alarms in Strata Units
  • Jono on WA: Resolving Strata Disputes Under the Strata Title Act Amendments
  • Allen G Reid on QLD: Changes to Strata Legislation and What This Means For You
  • Cindy on QLD: Q&A Installing Solar Panels in Strata in Queensland
  • Liza Admin on WA: Q&A Procedure for Appointing a New Strata Manager
  • Liza Admin on QLD: Q&As Management Rights, Extensions and the Committee’s Decision

WEBSITE INFORMATION

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions of Use
  • Terms of Use for Comments and Community Discussion
  • Advertising Disclosure
  • Sitemap

SCA Membership

SCA WA Membership

ASK A STRATA QUESTION

Disclaimer

The opinions and/or views expressed on the LookUpStrata site, including, but not limited to, our blogs and comments, represent the thoughts of individual bloggers and our online communities, and not those necessarily of LookUpStrata Pty Ltd. In all instances, information should not be taken as advice and independent legal advice should be consulted.

CONTACT US VIA EMAIL

Copyright © 2021 · LookUpStrata ® Pty Ltd · All rights reserved