Does a lot owner in a three-lot scheme need approval to paint or replace their roof or change external wall colours?

WA
Maintenance & Common Property
question
Lookupstrata community member

In a three-lot scheme with boundaries defined by section 3AB, does a lot owner need approval to paint or replace their roof, and can they freely change the colours of external walls and roofs as long as they aren't drastically different?

I am a lot owner in a three-lot scheme. At a recent AGM, our strata manager stated that as our lot boundaries are provided by Section 3AB, lot owners do not have to seek approval to paint, replace roofs, etc.

The strata manager also advised that our roofs and external walls do not have to be uniform in colour and that we can change the colours of external walls and roofs without approval as long as these are not glaringly different.

answer
WA Author Headshot Placeholder
Shane White Strata Title Consult PTY LTD

There is the opportunity to upgrade and refresh the appearance of the building within reason.

Whilst referring to the enquiry, I will confirm the following:

Boundaries

It is stated that the boundaries of the three lot scheme are covered by Section 3AB.

Section 3AB definition is now contained within Schedule 2A Part 2 – Lot Boundaries of the STA.

Alternative boundaries for lots in single tier strata schemes
  1. If this clause applies, the boundaries of a cubic space referred to in paragraph (a) of the definition of floor plan in section 3(1) are, regardless of the exact location of the lines referred to in that paragraph —
    1. the external surfaces of the building occupying the area represented on that floor plan —

      1. including any thing that —

        1. is attached to and projects from the building; and
        2. is prescribed by the regulations to be included as part of a lot;

        but

      2. excluding any thing that is prescribed by the regulations not to be included as part of a lot;

      or

    2. despite paragraph (a), if 2 lots —
      1. have a common or party wall, the centre plane of that wall; or
      2. have buildings on them that are joined, the plane or planes at which they are joined.

What does the STA mean when it states "including anything that" –

  1. is attached to and projects from the building; and
  2. is prescribed by the regulations to be included as part of a lot

The answer is found in the Strata Titles General Regulations 2019 (STGR) Schedule 1, Reg 4.

Reg 4. Boundaries of cubic space — things that are included

The following things are prescribed for the purposes of Schedule 2A clause 3AB(1)(a)(i)(II) as things to be included as part of a lot —

  1. hot water systems;
  2. refrigeration, air conditioning and cooling or heating plant or equipment;
  3. antennae or aerials for telecommunication;
  4. skylights;
  5. chimneys;
  6. roof ornaments;
  7. pipes, wires and cables;
  8. awnings, blinds, shutters and window grilles;
  9. light fittings;
  10. meter boxes;
  11. signs;
  12. renewable energy systems (such as solar panels or wind turbines);
  13. any thing of a kind similar to any of the things referred to in paragraphs (a) to (l).

All these listed attachments and things are part of the building.

The STGR also goes on to explain the following in Schedule 1, Reg 5:

Reg 5. Boundaries of cubic space — things that are excluded

The following are prescribed for Schedule 2A clause 3AB(1)(a)(ii) as things that are not to be included as part of a lot unless they are shown on the floor plan in respect of that lot —

  1. patios;
  2. carports and pergolas;
  3. enclosed rooms;
  4. storage rooms;
  5. any structure of a kind similar to any of the structures referred to in paragraphs (a) to (d).

It's important to observe that Sch1 Reg 5 states – "unless they are shown on the floor plan of the lot".

This will mean that those items referred to in Sch1 Reg 5 are not part of your lot and are common property.

In many older strata plans (pre 1985), even though the carport is attached to the building (the lot shown on the strata plan) and it is made from the same brickwork and same coloured roof tiles, it is common property as is not shown on the floor plan.

That is why the Merger Options came out in 1997. A story for another article.

Now, after explaining the Section 3AB ground rules, we have the question of the by-laws contained in Schedule 2 of the STA.

13. Notice of alteration to lot

An owner of a lot must not alter or permit the alteration of the structure of the lot except as may be permitted and provided for under the Act and the by-laws and in any event must not alter the structure of the lot without giving to the strata company, not later than 14 days before commencement of the alteration, a written notice describing the proposed alteration.

14. Appearance of lot

An owner or occupier of a lot must not, without the written consent of the strata company, maintain within the lot anything visible from outside the lot that, viewed from outside the lot, is not in keeping with the rest of the building.

15. Decoration of and affixing items to the inner surface of the lot

An owner or occupier of a lot must not, without the written consent of the strata company, paint, wallpaper or otherwise decorate a structure that forms the inner surface of the boundary of the lot or affix locking devices, flyscreens, furnishings, furniture, carpets and other similar things to that surface, if that action will unreasonably damage the common property.

Unless everyone in this three lot scheme agrees on different colours, you must have the same colour.

For something to be in keeping with the rest of the development, it could be similar or the same design features or in keeping without rigidly enforcing like for like.

Some things aren't made the same compared to 30 or 40 years ago, and some new items or "things" are better.

There is the opportunity to upgrade and refresh the appearance of the building within reason.

Consideration should be given to whether or not anyone else can see it and would it detract?

vector

Lookupstrata Directory

Looking for WA Strata Specialist in your area? Search within our LookUpStrata Directory for the best list of contacts available

Search the directory