Conflicting by-laws for camper trailer parking in strata

WA
Rules & Bylaws
Maintenance & Common Property
Committee & Governance
question
Lookupstrata community member

We have conflicting bylaws about camper trailers in parking bays. Which by-law prevails, and can the strata company refuse a request without considering its merits?

Our strata apartment complex has a conduct by-law that says owners can’t park a camper trailer in a part lot bay. Our current governance by-law says they can’t park a camper trailer without written consent.

Generally speaking, if a conduct by-law and a governance by-law conflict, which one prevails?

Can the strata company refuse to assess a request based on the conduct by-law, without considering the application for this camper trailer on its merits?

answer
Benjamin Sasson
Benjamin Sasson Vogt Legal

Neither type of by-law automatically overrides the other, and a strata company shouldn’t refuse a request without considering its merits.

Which by-law takes priority?

The Strata Titles Act 1985 (WA) (the Act) does not contain any provision that a governance by-law overrides a conduct by-law or vice versa.

Where possible, conflicting by-laws will generally be resolved by construing the two by-laws together, not by a hierarchy.

On its face, if one by-law prohibits parking a camper trailer within a part lot bay, and another by-law prohibits parking a camper trailer on common property without written consent, those by-laws do not appear to conflict.

That said, a question of validity may arise. A by-law is invalid to the extent that it is unfairly prejudicial, unfairly discriminatory, oppressive or unreasonable, having regard to the interests of all owners and the use and enjoyment of their lots and the common property. A blanket restriction with no rational connection to protecting other owners’ use and enjoyment may be vulnerable to being deemed invalid.

Can the strata company refuse the request without considering its merits?

Pursuant to section 119(1) of the Act, in performing its functions, a strata company is to have the objective of implementing processes and achieving outcomes that are not, having regard to the use and enjoyment of lots and common property in the strata titles scheme, unfairly prejudicial to or discriminatory against a person or oppressive or unreasonable. Subject to the circumstances, a refusal to grant consent without giving proper consideration to the merits of the request may amount to conduct in breach of the strata company’s obligations under section 119 of the Act.

What options are available?

Usually, if a dispute about the validity of a by-law or its enforcement cannot be resolved directly with the strata company, the matter can be referred to the State Administrative Tribunal for determination. Subject to the restrictions and limitations set out in the Act and the Strata Titles (General) Regulations 2019 (WA), the State Administrative Tribunal can, amongst other things:

  • declare a by-law invalid;
  • declare a decision of a strata company invalid;
  • order a strata company to take or refrain from specified action.

The above is provided for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. It is recommended that specific legal advice be obtained to determine whether there is any basis to challenge the validity of a by-law or a decision made by a strata company and the correct forum for doing so.

Related webinar

vector

Lookupstrata Directory

Looking for WA Strata Specialist in your area? Search within our LookUpStrata Directory for the best list of contacts available

Search the directory