Our by-laws say a structural alteration can be approved by the managing agent or council of owners. Isn't this in conflict with section 87 of the Act?
Our strata has a by-law that says a structural alteration can be approved by the managing agent or council of owners. Isn't this in conflict with the Strata Titles Act 1985, section 87 which says structural alterations need to be expressed by resolution without dissent of the strata company?
The by-law says:
Façades of the building
- A proprietor, occupier or other resident shall not modify, alter or erect or carry out any works to the facades of the building without the prior written approval of the council.
- Notwithstanding any other by-law, a proprietor of a lot shall not install or affix any structure, improvements or enclosures to a balcony or an external wall, roof or surface of the building unless it has been approved in writing by either the managing agent or the council of owners.
Section 87 refers specifically to structural alterations, whereas your by-laws refer to the facades of the building and any modification to the facade.
Section 87 refers specifically to structural alterations, whereas your by-laws refer to the facades of the building and any modification to the facade. Therefore as they refer to two different items, there does not appear to be a conflict.
In relation to Section 87 of the Act, it does confirm that a Lot Owner must not cause or permit the structural alteration of the lot unless they have prior approval, expressed by resolution without dissent. Section 89 and Section 90 also further clarifies the approvals and objection process. Section 123 (2) also confirms the details of a resolution without dissent. By-laws cannot contravene existing legislation, however, in this case they are referring to separate matters.
For example, the installation of an air-conditioner, front security screen door, awnings, patio blinds etc are not structural alterations but amendments to the façade and hence the Strata company wants to ensure that these items have written prior approval. The by-laws you refer to are similar to the Schedule 2 13 – Notice of alteration of Lot and 14 Appearance of Lot by-laws.
The Strata Titles Act doesn't define ""structural"", but if we reviewed the Standards Australia Handbook it notes Structural is ""describing an element or part of a building or structure that carries or transfers a load in addition to its own weight, as opposed to partitions, joinery or finishes"". Examples of structural changes would be moving or altering load-bearing walls or load-bearing roof elements such as rafters.
If any amendment is a structural alteration though, it will need to be adhered to and managed via the process of Sections 87 and 89 of the Act.
Lookupstrata Directory
Looking for WA Strata Specialist in your area? Search within our LookUpStrata Directory for the best list of contacts available
Search the directory
Comments
Log in to leave a comment