A lot owner has requested permission to add roller shutters to their windows and external awnings attached to the common property. Does the vote have to be unanimous or a majority?
We are a 90s built strata property. A lot owner has requested permission to add roller shutters to their windows and external awnings attached to the common property.
The requests have been added to the AGM agenda for a vote. Does the vote have to be unanimous or a majority? Also, what is the difference between an ordinary and a special resolution? We have never understood the difference when trying to work out voting rules.
Three options are available for achieving the desired outcome, along with the relevant sections of the Strata Titles Act that govern these options.
Please note: We included a response to this question in the February edition of The WA Strata Magazine. After receiving audience feedback, the article was removed from the magazine and updated to include more information.
What are the ground rules for this answer?
Firstly
What are the boundaries of the strata scheme, particularly the buildings:
- Common property, OR
- Part Lot
These two things can have a great impact on the answer due to that uncertainty and the options available to the owner in each instance.
There is the assumption from the information given (assumption by the writer of the question) that the ""alterations"" will be going on common property. (So, let's run with that assumption as the strata plan is not available).
What Resolution is Required?
The owner of the lot doesn't own the walls or the windows (assuming that the boundaries are covered under section 3(2)(a) of the STA).
The owner would own the internal surfaces of the floor, walls and ceilings, this leaving all the walls, doors and windows forming the boundary of the lot as common property.
Option 1
Section 43 - EXCLUSIVE USE
Exclusive Use is covered under section 43 of the STA and requires a Resolution Without Dissent (RWD).
This entails a general meeting with a favourable result, and a letter of consent from the owner getting the benefit of the exclusive use see section 43.(5) STA.
A suitably drafted by-law setting out the terms and conditions of such use as per section 43.(2) and (3) STA.
A description of where the exclusive use area is located by narrative or defined by a sketch done by a Surveyor.
This briefly means that if you install it, you must maintain it as if it was common property owned by the strata company. (see Section 91(1)(c) STA).
Option 2
Section 64 – COMMON PROPERTY (UTILITY AND SUSTAINABILITY INFRASTRUCTURE) EASEMENT
- This section applies if —
- a strata company has entered into a contract (an infrastructure contract) with a person under which the person owns and operates utility infrastructure or sustainability infrastructure on common property in the strata titles scheme; and
- this section is applied to the infrastructure contract by ordinary resolution of the strata company.
- An infrastructure contract must —
- specify the common property over which there is an easement under this section; and
- specify the infrastructure to which the easement applies.
- The person (the infrastructure owner) who, from time to time, owns the infrastructure the subject of an infrastructure contract has an easement over the common property specified in the infrastructure contract that entitles the infrastructure owner —
- to install and remove the infrastructure specified in the contract; and
- to operate that infrastructure; and
- to examine, maintain, repair, modify and replace that infrastructure.
- The easement is subject to any conditions set out in the infrastructure contract (as in force from time to time).
- The infrastructure contract may be varied by agreement between the strata company and the person who is the infrastructure owner from time to time.
- The easement ceases to exist if the infrastructure contract is terminated or otherwise ceases to have effect.
- The rights conferred by the easement must be exercised so as to minimise, as far as reasonably practicable, interference with the enjoyment and use of the common property.
- The regulations may —
- specify special procedures for notice or voting on the resolution required for the application of this section; and
- set out terms and conditions that are to be taken to be implied in an infrastructure contract; and
- otherwise regulate the rights and obligations of the strata company and the infrastructure owner.
The affixing of an awning or roller shutter would be a sustainability item whereby the lot owner would achieve a reduction in the transference of heat or cold.
These two options provide very similar requirements for approval but the resolution required is different.
Option 3
This is an option that I would put out there that would also achieve the same outcome.
Section 91. General Duty
A strata company must —
- [deleted]
- control and manage the common property for the benefit of all the owners of lots; and
- keep in good and serviceable repair, properly maintain and, if necessary, renew and replace —
- the common property, including the fittings, fixtures and lifts used in connection with the common property; and
- any personal property owned by the strata company, and to do so whether damage or deterioration arises from fair wear and tear, inherent defect or any other cause.
[(d)-(k) deleted]
- A strata company may improve or alter the common property in a manner that goes beyond what is required under subsection (1).
Note for this subsection: Expenditure above a certain amount incurred for the purposes set out in subsection (2) must be authorised by special resolution, except for expenditure on sustainability infrastructure, which may be authorised by ordinary resolution: see section 102.
What if the strata company approved proposals that owners could improve the common property on the basis that it was self funded by the lot owner?
The conditions of approval would be subject to either option 1 or option 2 above. A License doesn't apply.
The following paragraphs have been taken from SAT Case [2023] WASAT 101. Saje and Sampson. [in Italics]
While the strata company can make improvements or alterations to the common property as provided for in s 91(2) of the ST Act, the same provision is not afforded to lot owners.
A licence would be available for someone who wants to have, say a shop, on the common property. Further, a licence has to be to a third party, but not to a member of the strata company, which is the case here. However, it does not mean that the strata company can issue a licence to a member of the strata company to build unauthorised structures on the common property or to increase the size of a lot or to change the lot borders.
The ST Act does not have a provision to allow a licence for structural alterations to the common property by lot owners. In any event, a lot owner cannot build structures that change lot boundaries.
The context of these statements relates to the Strata Company inappropriately using the facility of the provisions of a license incorrectly.
To be clear, under the ST Act each lot owner has an undivided share in the common property and therefore all of the owners must consent to alterations to such common property before they may occur. This is an underlying principle of the management and control of common property under the ST Act: see Maber & Anor and The Owners of Strata Plan 11391 [2007] WASAT 99 at [29] and Pitsikas and Grimes [2009] WASAT 80 at [24]
There is also an underlying assumption in the ST Act that a lot owner must seek approval from the strata company for a 'structure' to be located on common property prior to doing any works on the common property. The owner who fails to seek approval from all fellow owners (that is, the strata company) by having a 'structure' located on the common property may be required to remove the 'structure' and restore the common property. This occurred in Wong v Reid [2016] WASC 59 (Wong v Reid) where the Supreme Court dismissed Mr Wong's application seeking leave to appeal against the decision of the Tribunal requiring Mr Wong to remove a wall he had constructed on common property in a strata scheme without consent of all of the owners in the strata scheme and to arrange for the reconstitution of the garden on the common property.
The Resolutions
The details about resolutions can be found at Section 123 STA.
Lookupstrata Directory
Looking for WA Strata Specialist in your area? Search within our LookUpStrata Directory for the best list of contacts available
Search the directory
Comments
Log in to leave a comment