Can the council rewrite an owner’s AGM motions?

WA
Committee & Governance
Rules & Bylaws
question
Lookupstrata community member

An owner submitted several separate motions for the AGM, but the notice grouped them under one resolution. Can an owner’s motions be adjusted without consent?

Six weeks before our AGM notice was issued, I submitted several items to the council and strata manager under section 129(4) of the Strata Titles Act 1985 (the Act). Each included a brief explanation and a proposed motion.

The notice reproduced and numbered the motions, but grouped them under one proposed resolution. The explanations were merged into one continuous paragraph, making it difficult to match each explanation to its motion, or to know whether they would be voted on separately.

Does the Act allow the council or strata manager to change an owner’s submission? Should the notice include the motion and enough context for owners to make an informed decision? Does the Strata Community Association (WA) AGM Best Practice Guide require a higher professional standard?

answer
Marietta Metzger
Marietta Metzger magixstrata

An owner’s submitted business should be included substantially as submitted, and the council or strata manager should consult the owner before condensing or rewriting it.

Section 129(4) of the Strata Titles Act 1985 (WA) provides that an owner of a lot may give written notice to a member of the council of the strata company of an item of business that the owner requires to be included on the agenda for a general meeting. The section further provides that the item must be included on the agenda for the meeting, and notice must be given of that item as special business.

The wording of section 129(4) is important. It gives an owner a statutory right to require an item of business to be included on the agenda. The Act does not contain any express provision allowing the council of owners or the strata manager to alter, condense, consolidate or rewrite an item of business submitted by an owner under section 129(4).

Accordingly, where an owner submits several separate items of business, each containing a proposed motion and a brief explanation, the appropriate approach is to include the items on the agenda substantially as submitted. There may be reasonable administrative formatting, such as allocating agenda numbers, correcting obvious typographical errors or formatting the submission consistently with the remainder of the agenda. However, that is different from materially changing the owner’s submission.

In particular, combining several separate motions under one proposed resolution, or combining and rearranging the explanations into one paragraph so that owners cannot readily identify which explanation relates to which motion, may materially change the manner in which the owner’s submitted business is presented. If separate motions were submitted, they should remain readily identifiable as separate items unless the submitting owner agrees to their consolidation.

When preparing the AGM agenda, it is also not ordinarily the role of the strata manager or the council to determine that an owner’s proposed motion should be rewritten, consolidated with another motion, or otherwise changed because they consider a different formulation preferable. The statutory requirement is that the owner’s item of business be included on the agenda. Whether a proposed motion is ultimately valid, what type of resolution it may require, whether it can lawfully be implemented, or whether owners choose to support it are separate questions. Where there is genuine doubt about the legal validity of a proposed resolution, legal advice can be obtained rather than changing the owner’s submitted business without consultation.

Section 129(2)(c) also requires the notice of a general meeting to give notice of the general nature of any special business to be transacted at the meeting. However, this general notice requirement should be distinguished from the specific right provided to an owner by section 129(4). Where an owner has exercised that right by submitting a particular item of business and proposed motion, merely identifying the broad topic of the owner’s proposal would not necessarily amount to including the item of business that the owner actually required to be placed on the agenda.

The Strata Community Association (WA) Best Practice Guide: Annual General Meetings (March 2025) does not specifically address section 129(4), nor does it state whether an owner’s submitted item of business may be altered, condensed, consolidated or rewritten by the council or strata manager. The Guide refers generally to section 127 as identifying what must be included in the notice and the requirement for the notice of the meeting to be given in writing to each lot owner.

The Guide provides relevant general guidance on preparing an AGM agenda. It states that the agenda should include, where necessary, the text of proposed resolutions and/or information to enable informed decisions at the meeting. It also states that the agenda should include all obligations of the strata company that “must” be included under the Act.

Similarly, regarding supporting documents, the Guide recommends providing the information necessary to ensure owners can make informed decisions at the meeting.

The SCA (WA) Guide therefore provides useful general guidance about presenting sufficient information to owners, but it does not impose any additional or higher requirement specifically in relation to section 129(4). The Guide itself states that it is only a guide and is not legal advice.

In summary, section 129(4) does not expressly authorise the council or strata manager to substitute their own condensed or reformulated version of an owner’s submitted item of business. Where an owner has submitted separate motions with explanations, the safer and more appropriate approach is to reproduce those items substantially as submitted, keeping each motion and its corresponding explanation identifiable. If the council or strata manager believes consolidation or amendment would improve the agenda, the preferable course is to consult the submitting owner and obtain their agreement before making any substantive alteration.

Ultimately, if there is a dispute about whether an AGM notice complied with section 129(4), or whether alterations made to an owner’s submitted business were sufficiently material to constitute non-compliance with the Act, that is a question on which independent legal advice may be required.The above information is general in nature and should not be considered legal advice.

Related webinar

vector

Lookupstrata Directory

Looking for WA Strata Specialist in your area? Search within our LookUpStrata Directory for the best list of contacts available

Search the directory