A body corporate assumed it was responsible for duplex wall repairs, then learned it wasn’t. Can it now decline to pay?
Our scheme has three-level units on a building format plan, plus a two-storey duplex and two standalone family homes on a standard format plan.
We understand what the body corporate is responsible for with the units, and that the owners are responsible for the standalone homes. But until recently, we believed the body corporate was responsible for the duplex’s external and shared walls.
An external leak caused by settlement or movement in one unit led to internal water damage to the unit below. On the advice of their real estate agent, the owner sent us a report and a quote for the repairs. We told our body corporate manager we’d have to pay, and they promptly told the new owner, so work started without us issuing a work order.
Two weeks ago we asked the body corporate manager to clarify, and they told us we’re not responsible for anything on the duplex apart from the shared guttering. We haven’t received the invoice yet, but we need solid confirmation of exactly what we’re responsible for. Can we admit our mistake, expalin we believed it was building format, and say we won’t pay?
Responsibility depends on the cause of the damage, and a body corporate that isn’t responsible can retract an earlier assumption that it was.
Who is responsible for the repairs primarily depends on the cause of the damage.
Without access to expert building advice that confirms the cause of damage in detail, we cannot provide a definitive comment on who is responsible in this case.
Generally, in a standard format plan of subdivision:
- the body corporate must maintain common property and body corporate assets in good condition (which includes common property utility infrastructure); and
- lot owners must maintain the lot in good condition.
As an exception to the general position, a lot owner must also maintain the following items that are part of common property in good condition:
- improvements made by the lot owner;
- fixtures or fittings installed for the benefit of the lot;
- the shower tray for the lot;
- utility infrastructure that is connected to a device that only supplies services to one lot; and
- exclusive use areas, unless the exclusive use by-law provides otherwise.
If a person is not responsible for maintenance, it can retract an assumption that it was responsible for the repairs.
In Coomera Waters [2023] QBCCMCmr 203 it was found:
“The submissions indicate the PBC has always been accepted as the beneficial owner of the revetment wall and a precedent has been set. I assume the PBC has previously taken on responsibility for the revetment wall because of By-law 41. However, I do not consider the PBC can be deemed to have a legal obligation to maintain something it otherwise has no valid legal responsibility for because it previously assumed responsibilities it did not legally have. If others are legally responsible for the revetment wall, they will have benefited from the PBC taking on a responsibility that it may not have. That does not mean the benefit must continue.”
Related webinar
Lookupstrata Directory
Looking for QLD Strata Specialist in your area? Search within our LookUpStrata Directory for the best list of contacts available
Search the directory
Comments
Log in to leave a comment