Does a strata auditor make recommendations about unwise expenditures by the owners corporation?

NSW
Committee & Governance
question
Lookupstrata community member

Does an auditor make sensible recommendations about the cost-benefit of unwise expenditures?

Will an auditor make sensible recommendations about the cost-benefit of unwise expenditures? For example, many schemes spend more on annual taxation compliance than they earn in non-mutual income instead of shifting funds into non-interest earning accounts and negating any obligations with the ATO.

answer
Rod Laws
Rod Laws Tinworth & Co

No, it's outside the scope of the audit engagement to make recommendations on unwise expenditure.

I'll break the question into two pieces.

The first answer is no, that's outside the scope of the audit engagement to make recommendations on unwise expenditure. Just like the shareholders of BHP appoint the directors of BHP to run the company for them, the owners appoint the committee to run the affairs of the Owners Corporation on their behalf with the help of the agent. So if again, referring back to my presentation, if the Owners Corporation decides to paint the fence green instead of painting the fence black, it's their decision to make. It's not really in the scope of the audit whether the fence should be green or black.

To answer the second part of the question, I agree. Especially with record low interest rates at the moment, it's often very little benefit of receiving $2 or $3 in interest in an interest bearing account and then having to pay a tax agent to prepare a return.

You need to also be mindful that interest is not the only item of assessable income for an Owners Corporation that triggers the requirement to lodge a tax return. Remember, an Owners Corporation is taxed as a company so as soon as that company earns $1 in assessable income, you have to prepare and lodge a tax return. But I do sympathise with the point.

The other thing you need to be mindful of, and we see this a lot, is that everyone thinks 'I don't have any assessable income in my Owners Corporation, therefore I don't have to lodge a return'. Tick, that's correct. However, when a return is not lodged at all, what happens is in two, three or four years and sometimes 19 years later, the Commissioner writes to the current tax agent to say 'Your 2002 income tax return remains outstanding. I am now ordering you to lodge a return even if it is nil', and if you don't do that, within the required timeframe, the Commissioner finds you $900 per year. What we do, as part of a service to make sure that it's complete is we lodge what's called a CEU form or a client update form. So yes, if you need to lodge a return, we lodge a return. If you don't need to lodge a return, we tell the commissioner in that year that you don't need to lodge a return so that you won't get those letters in three, four and five years saying 'I'm now directing you to lodge a return'.

vector

Lookupstrata Directory

Looking for NSW Strata Specialist in your area? Search within our LookUpStrata Directory for the best list of contacts available

Search the directory