Can a by-law ban hard flooring and force the installation of carpet in bedrooms?

NSW
Rules & Bylaws
Committee & Governance
question
Lookupstrata community member

A carpet-only bedroom by-law was passed while an owner’s tile application was still pending. Can it be challenged at NCAT as harsh, unconscionable or oppressive?

Our by-laws prohibited timber flooring in bedrooms. Relying on that restriction, I lodged an application to install tiles throughout my apartment. The strata committee was unhappy with the application, but acknowledged that, technically, they couldn’t refuse it under the existing by-law.

The strata committee then moved to repeal that by-law and introduce a more restrictive by-law while my application was pending. The new by-law bans all hard flooring in bedrooms, regardless of the material, acoustic performance or installation method. It was passed with a 76% majority.

The timing suggests the by-law was designed to stop my pending application, rather than introduced as a genuinely necessary or reasonable measure for the benefit of the whole scheme.

I’ve researched NCAT decisions, including Mackinnon v Greenway. Are there grounds to argue the new by-law is harsh, unconscionable or oppressive under section 139(1) of the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015? Should NCAT make an order under section 150 declaring it invalid?

Could introducing a much more restrictive by-law while a formal flooring application was being considered be evidence of an improper purpose, or of an attempt to get around the existing by-laws? What would the strongest legal grounds be?

answer
Chris Kim
Chris Kim Benson Legal Pty Ltd

A by-law that bans all hard flooring or requires carpet in every bedroom is likely invalid because it conflicts with the minor renovation provisions.

Subject to the actual words of the by-law, a by-law that imposes a blanket prohibition on timber flooring or tiles, or mandates all bedrooms to have carpet in every circumstance, is likely invalid.

This is on the basis that such a by-law would be inconsistent with section 110 of the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 (the Act), which provides that an owner can carry out ‘minor renovations’ to common property in connection with the owner’s lot and with the approval of the owners corporation at a general meeting. Critically, the definition of ‘minor renovations’ includes at section 110(3)(c) “installing or replacing wood or other hard floors”.

A by-law providing a blanket prohibition on wood or other hard floors would be inconsistent with section 110 of the Act, and section 136(2) of the Act provides that “a by-law has no force or effect to the extent that it is inconsistent with this or any other Act or law”.

This can be seen in Gurram v Owners Corporation SP 36589 [2018] NSWCATCD 39, where the following by-law was held to be invalid for being inconsistent with section 110 of the Act at [11]. The NCAT further held at [16] that the by-law was ‘harsh, unconscionable and oppressive’ for purposes of section 150 of the Act as well.

“That no hard flooring such as timber or ceramic floor tiles be permitted to be installed in any of the lots in the Strata Plan 36589 except for ground floor units...”

The Gurram case was applied in Mackinnon v Greenway [2020] NSWCATCD 28 [40], where it was held that a by-law that had very onerous acoustic requirements for wooden floors was harsh, unconscionable and oppressive.

Accordingly, it is not necessary to allege and prove that the timing of the change to the by-law is a breach of the strata committee and the owners corporation duties in section 37 of the Act, or contributes to the finding that the by-law is ‘harsh, unconscionable and oppressive’.

We recommend that you provide a written notice to the owners corporation in accordance with section 110(4) of the Act, and also outlining the above. This is to avoid litigation, but if litigation is required, to satisfy the procedural requirements in section 232(2) of the Act.

Please note that the above is general information only and does not constitute legal advice. You should obtain independent legal advice regarding your particular circumstances.

Related webinar

vector

Lookupstrata Directory

Looking for NSW Strata Specialist in your area? Search within our LookUpStrata Directory for the best list of contacts available

Search the directory