Property damage and insurance: What you need to know?

QLD
Maintenance & Common Property
Insurance
Rules & Bylaws

Property damage, whether as a result of severe weather, water ingress, fire, or other unforeseen events, is an unfortunate reality of apartment living for many lot owners and bodies corporate.

Fortunately, the insurance taken out by the Body Corporate exists for the benefit of all lot owners at the Scheme.

In Baden East [2025] QBCCMCmr 466 (Baden Decision) Adjudicator I Rosemann found:

The legislation requires the body corporate to hold building insurance to protect the property interests of owners and occupiers as well as the body corporate. Accordingly, owners and occupiers have a right, whether directly or via the body corporate, to make claims on that insurance for any property damage that is covered by the insurance policy.

But what happens when the insurance policy does not cover the damage or there are delays in processing the claim?

It is important to remember that, irrespective of whether damage is covered by an insurance policy, the person who is legally responsible for maintenance and repairs under the legislation does not change.

In Beaumont [2009] QBCCMCmr 240 it was found:

Accordingly, I am satisfied that the Body Corporate is responsible for the damage caused by the water leak and the cost of rectifying the damage.

… regardless of whether or not the Body Corporate has insurance which covered the relevant event or damage, or whether the applicant had insurance which covered the relevant event or damage, the Body Corporate is responsible for the damage.

…The onus was on the Body Corporate to rectify the damage itself, or pay the applicant for the cost of the rectification. It was an entirely separate matter, beyond the interest or responsibility of the applicant, whether the Body Corporate was able to recover any of the costs of the work.

In circumstances where the insurance claim is delayed or refused, the affected lot owner or Body Corporate may pursue the responsible party directly to have the property damage resolved.

This will ordinarily involve:

  • obtaining expert building advice that links the property damage to a cause that the responsible party must maintain pursuant to the Body Corporate and Community Management Act 1997 and regulation module; and
  • making a dispute application at the Office of the Commissioner for Body Corporate and Community Management against the responsible party for an outcome that the responsible party repair the property damage.

An adjudicator at the Office of the Commissioner for Body Corporate and Community Management will only award:

  • up to $10,000 as a reimbursement for repairs carried out by the Applicant; or
  • up to $75,000 to carry out the repair works.

If the costs exceed the jurisdictional limits, proceedings will need to be commenced in a Court or Tribunal of competent jurisdiction.

Where an insurance claim is accepted, it does not necessarily follow that the Body Corporate is liable to pay the insurance excess.

Relevantly, section 203 of the Body Corporate and Community Management (Standard Module) Regulation 2020 provides that:

  • Where an event affects only one lot, the owner of the lot is liable to pay the insurance excess, unless the Body Corporate decides that it is unreasonable in all the circumstances for the owner to bear the liability.
  • Where an event affects two or more lots, or one or more lots and common property, the Body Corporate is liable to pay the excess unless the Body Corporate decides it is reasonable in all the circumstances for the excess to be paid by the owner of a particular lot, or shared between owners of particular lots or owners of particular lots and the body corporate

In Whitsunday Harbour Stage B [2013] QBCCMCmr 413 Adjudicator C Partridge found that it would be reasonable for the party responsible for the property damage under the legislation to bear the insurance excess, relevantly providing (our emphasis):

As previously stated, section 182(4) of the Accommodation Module provides the body corporate pays the insurance excess for an event that affects two lots unless the body corporate considers it reasonable in all the circumstances for the insurance excess to be paid by an owner of a lot. The flooding did affect two lots. However, the cause of the flooding related only to the applicant’s lot. Due to the cause of the leak, the committee have determined that the applicant should pay the full excess amount.

…There is no allegation that the applicant did anything to cause the pipe to burst. The applicant also did the right thing in claiming the damage under the body corporate’s insurance policy as that insurance policy exists to help owners recover from events of this nature. However, there is no legal basis for requiring the body corporate to pay the excess instead of the applicant. The pipe that burst is the responsibility of the applicant and the decision by the committee to require the applicant pay the excess is not objectively unreasonable.

This article has been republished with permission from the author and first appeared on the Mahoneys website.

Related webinar

vector

Lookupstrata Directory

Looking for QLD Strata Specialist in your area? Search within our LookUpStrata Directory for the best list of contacts available

Search the directory