How do we fix a sinking fund shortfall after legal overspends?

QLD
Committee & Governance
Levies & Finance
question
Lookupstrata community member

Legal fee overspends were covered by diverting sinking fund contributions to the admin fund, and now the sinking fund is short. What can owners do?

Our committee overspent the legal fees budget by $32,000 in 2022, on top of a $13,000 overspend on legal fees in 2021. We have 73 lots.

At an EGM in 2023, owners voted not to pay their sinking fund contribution and instead to pay the same amount into the admin fund. Now, in 2026, our sinking fund holds $120,000 when it should hold almost $200,000. What can we do?

answer
William Marquand
William Marquand Tower Body Corporate

You can’t change past decisions, so focus on topping up the sinking fund and on practical options from now on.

You can’t change the past, so the best advice is to look forward.

A lot of body corporate energy is spent trying to correct past decisions that people think were wrong. In my experience, the time and angst that go into this are usually unproductive.

Think about practical solutions. If your sinking fund is insufficient, owners will have to raise more funds to top it up. If committee members have made incorrect decisions in the past, nominate to replace them. Accept the position you are in and work on strategies to improve it.

Are there any other options? In specific circumstances, perhaps you could refer an issue to your insurer. It may be possible to make a claim for legal expenses if there was a rationale to do so. If the committee members acted negligently or against the law, maybe office bearers liability would cover you. It’s worth asking the broker, but know that any claim may be high risk. At a minimum, it will impact your claims history.

Some schemes undertake a forensic audit, a deep dive into the accounts, particularly with a view towards finding out if there has been any wrongdoing. There are circumstances when these can be beneficial, but the audit is expensive and doesn’t recover money on its own. We don’t know all the facts, but in this case it sounds more like overspending rather than anything nefarious.

The other choice would be to speak to a lawyer and see if there was any legal case that could be brought. Of course, you say that high legal fees brought about some of the current circumstances, so there may be reluctance to do that, but it is an option on the table.

Lastly, as you say, the legal fees caused an overspend. Maybe think about what those fees were for and whether they led to any resolution. Sometimes you can have a trigger-happy committee that calls a lawyer for every minor dispute, and fees can get out of control that way. On the other hand, legal cases can be complicated and, once started, can be hard to exit. Maybe the committee had to navigate a complex body corporate issue with the caretaker or some other liability concern. Expenditure may have been higher than expected, but that doesn’t mean it was wrong. Sometimes you have to accept that running a body corporate costs money and move on.

Related webinar

vector

Lookupstrata Directory

Looking for QLD Strata Specialist in your area? Search within our LookUpStrata Directory for the best list of contacts available

Search the directory