Can exclusive use improvement provisions be removed when a caretaker lot is sold to an ordinary owner?

QLD
Parking & Storage
Maintenance & Common Property
question
Lookupstrata community member

In our development a lot intended for the caretaker included provisions to make improvements to the exclusive use area without seeking approval. However, the lot was sold to an owner. Can the provisions now be removed?

We are a complex of 140 units/villas under the accommodation module and building format plan.

The original developer's DA included a provision for one of the Lots to make improvements to the exclusive use area without seeking the approval of the BC. Too many to mention here but for example: Install a swimming pool, install a spa, install children's play equipment.

The original intention was that the Lot would be allocated to the caretaker manager and the conditions were included in the CMS By-laws. The Lot was not allocated to the caretaker manager, but the By-law remains in place which means the owner can carry out the improvements without prior approval.

One Lot owner has an exclusive right not afforded to the other 139 owners.

The opinion is that the By-Law can't be revoked because the owner can claim the decision to purchase the Lot was based on the conditions in the By-Law. Is this opinion correct?

answer
Todd Garsden
Todd Garsden Mahoneys

An exclusive use by-law can only be revoked by a resolution without dissent and the benefitting lot owner's consent.

An exclusive use by-law can only be revoked by a resolution without dissent and the benefitting lot owner's consent. There is no ability to revoke the allocation on the basis that it is considered unfair to other owners. The benefitting lot owner may have relied on the rights granted in the CMS (as they are entitled to do) and purchased the lot on the basis that those rights would exist – so on one hand it would be unfair if this could be taken away. There would seemingly need to be some form of technical validity issue with the original grant for it to be challenged.

vector

Lookupstrata Directory

Looking for QLD Strata Specialist in your area? Search within our LookUpStrata Directory for the best list of contacts available

Search the directory