Can an owner's motion drastically cut the committee's spending limit?

QLD
Committee & Governance
Levies & Finance
Rules & Bylaws
question
Lookupstrata community member

An owner's AGM motion proposes to cut the committee's discretionary spending limit drastically. Should the chairperson rule it out of order?

As a committee, we've received an owner's motion for our AGM that says: "That an ordinary resolution be passed, at this general meeting, to decrease discretionary expenditure by the Strata Committee, from $300 to $13.70 per lot. This relates to expenditure which is not emergency in nature, and not provided for in the relevant approved budget, and not expressly authorised or required under the Body Corporate and Community Management legislation".

The explanatory note says "This applies only to unbudgeted discretionary spending above $1,000 (decreasing the $300 per lot to $13.70 per lot)". It does not indicate what would happen if the motion passed, i.e. we'd need an EGM for almost any committee spending decision in our 73-lot complex.

Does this motion let the committee spend outside the budget, and is it against the legislation? It's unclear how it would apply if passed, as the legislation doesn't define discretionary spending, only budgeted spending. Should the chairperson rule it invalid at the AGM?

answer
Michael Kleinschmidt
Michael Kleinschmidt Bugden Allen

The motion should be ruled out of order, because the legislation has no concept of 'discretionary' spending, only committee spending up to the relevant limit or spending approved at a general meeting.

Pulling levers that aren't there…

Body corporate spending is heavily regulated under the Body Corporate and Community Management Act 1997.

The general scheme of the legislation is that there is a limit (the 'relevant limit for committee spending') under which a committee may spend body corporate funds, and over which some other sort of approval is required; e.g. approval by the lot owners at a general meeting, by an adjudicator to meet an emergency, to comply with an order (adjudicator, QCAT or Court) or some statutory notice or order, or all lot owners agree in writing.

The Standard Module provides that the 'relevant limit for committee spending' is the amount last set by ordinary resolution, or, if there is no limit that has been set, then an amount equal to $200 times the number of lots in the scheme.

By passing the necessary ordinary resolutions, lot owners can dial up or down the relevant limit for committee spending to suit their preferences for how much spending power the committee should have, without having to come back to the lot owners for prior approval of a larger spend.

If, for one moment, we are generous in our interpretation of the motion, we could say that what it tries to achieve is to lower the relevant limit for committee spending down (a lot!) so that any spending over $1,000 would require a general meeting to approve (unless one of the other 'carve outs' above applies).

Now, as a matter of practicality, $1,000 gets you a bag of peanuts these days, so to speak, with respect to anything to do with bodies corporate. For a 73 lot scheme, $1,000 is a very impractical limit and would almost certainly be (at least fiscally) counterproductive. The costs of calling general meetings to vote on relatively minor spending would likely outweigh the cost of the spending itself!

Fortuitously for the committee, the motion has significant enough problems that it should be ruled out of order.

First, it cannot be given effect to. Under the Act and Module, there is no notion or concept of 'discretionary' spending. There is committee spending, or spending approved at a general meeting… full stop.

Second, it is contrary to the Act. For example, it would purport to have the effect of limiting committee spending on compliance with (non-emergency) orders of a court or tribunal to $1,000 only, when the Module expressly provides that the relevant limit for committee spending does not apply in such a case.

The explanatory note hints at the lot owner's motivations, i.e. the limit 'applies only to unbudgeted discretionary spending'. Budgets don't approve spending; they approve raising funds so the money is on hand when the spending is approved. If the spending is necessary but has not been budgeted for, it can still be approved, with one catch. A special contribution has to be raised to get the funds in, in essence to make sure that the relevant body corporate fund (administrative or sinking) is topped back up to where it should be.

This lot owner looks to be wanting to pull a lever to stop special levies being issued, at least without the lot owner having some advance notice, by dramatically curtailing what the committee can spend on, without lot owner approval first. The problem for this lot owner is that they are reaching out to pull a lever that is not there: motions cannot be used to control 'discretionary' spending by the committee.

What the lot owner can do is to propose a change to the relevant limit for committee spending. What they cannot do is try to circumvent the committee's powers (rightly and necessarily) to authorise spending on matters Parliament has approved.

Related webinar

Comments

Log in to leave a comment
Michael Kleinschmidt
Michael Kleinschmidt Guidance partner
18 Nov 2026
Comment

Hi Ross, thanks for your interest in this article. In line with my 'tough love' approach, to me there are only two forms of 'discretionary' spending: (A) spending that is not required, but is permitted by the legislation e.g. improvements to common property such as a spa, next to the current swimming pool; and (B) the amount of spending above what the legislation mandates money must be raised and spent on e.g. whether you use a no name paint brand to paint the building, or the best that Dulux has to offer. The cost of living crisis affects everyone (me included!) but lot owners should beware false economies. There is nothing 'fair', or 'unfair', about budgets. They are what they have to be. In my view, budgets should always cover the expected realistic price for what needs to be paid for, plus a small margin. The commitee, and if necessary lot owners, can then make comfortable decisions about quotes when they are received, rather than having to rush back to an EGM to raise a special levy.

Ross Anderson
Ross Anderson Guidance partner
17 Nov 2026
Comment

Michael...many thanks for this.

Re 'discretionary' expenditure. You make it plain there is no such concept in the leg'n when drafting rules re spending.
However, I feel it does warrant acknowledgment and consideration when setting out budgets and levies for the AGM, especially for a Sinking fund, and relatively large amounts are signalled for improvements, and bundled in with the 'necessaries' for maintenance of what is already there. The owners are then presented with an 'all or nothing' vote, and this does not seem fair to me.
Surely the improvements are 'discretionary' in this context, and it would help if owners are given a choice between a 'basics' budget and a 2nd budget with all of the extras? That way they can actually see the difference between the two, in real $$ terms, and make an informed choice?
Ross Anderson AQUO

vector

Lookupstrata Directory

Looking for QLD Strata Specialist in your area? Search within our LookUpStrata Directory for the best list of contacts available

Search the directory