A strata managing agent reordered owner-requisitioned EGM motions without consultation, and the chair dismissed by-law breach motions without discussion. Were they entitled to?
A group of owners called an EGM and gave the strata managing agent a list of motions, asking that they stay in the order provided and that the owners see the draft motions before the notice of EGM went out. Both requests were ignored, and the notice was sent without review.
We later found out that the secretary, who was appointed after the EGM was requested and is the subject of a by-law breach motion, had reordered the motions with the strata managing agent. Their motion was placed at the very end of the agenda, which we believe is a conflict of interest.
When we asked to reorder some motions at the start of the meeting, the strata managing agent, who was chairing, refused. The by-law breach motions were then dismissed without any discussion.
Was the strata managing agent entitled to change the order of the motions and send the notice without owner review, and was the chair entitled to dismiss the by-law breach motions without discussion?
Reordering motions isn’t prohibited, but a chair shouldn’t dismiss valid motions without letting the owners corporation consider and vote on them.
There is no requirement under the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 (NSW) for requisitioning owners to approve the final notice of an EGM before it is issued, nor is there a legislative requirement that motions appear in the exact order submitted.
However, where owners have requisitioned an EGM and specifically requested a particular order of motions, changing that order without consultation may raise legitimate concerns about procedural fairness, particularly if the changes appear to benefit a person who is the subject of one of the motions.
The more significant issue is how the by-law breach motions were handled at the meeting. A chairperson’s role is to facilitate the meeting and ensure motions are considered in accordance with the legislation and the meeting procedures. Unless a motion is invalid, unlawful, or otherwise out of order, the chair should not simply dismiss it without allowing the owners corporation to consider and vote on it.
If valid motions were excluded from consideration or dismissed without discussion or a vote, the affected owners may have grounds to challenge the conduct of the meeting through NSW Fair Trading mediation and, if necessary, NCAT.
In these circumstances, the key question is not whether the motions were reordered, but whether the meeting was conducted in a manner that deprived owners of the opportunity to have properly submitted motions considered and determined by the owners corporation.
Related webinar
Lookupstrata Directory
Looking for NSW Strata Specialist in your area? Search within our LookUpStrata Directory for the best list of contacts available
Search the directory
Comments
Log in to leave a comment