This article about Body Corporate Managers QLD has been supplied by Wayne Stevens, Unit Owners Association of Queensland (UOAQ).
Q: Is there a problem that needs fixing? A: Many suspect so, but no one really knows for sure.
There is an abundance of anecdotal information, supported by formal evidence like reported Adjudications, which informs us that there are many owners, and even strata professionals, who are concerned about the professional conduct of some Body Corporate Managers in QLD.
Anyone can operate as a Body Corporate Manager in QLD, regardless of qualifications, or experience, or integrity… or lack thereof. Anyone can operate as a Body Corporate Manager in QLD, regardless of qualifications, or experience, or integrity… or lack thereof. Even the BCCM Commissioner’s web-site acknowledges this. But, how do you sort the good from the bad? Whom do you go to for assurance about the competency and integrity of any Body Corporate Manager, whether incumbent or prospective?
If you have enjoyed this content and would like to be kept informed about strata matters, click here to subscribe to our weekly newsletter.
Not to the Adjudicators. Adjudicators adjudicate: they deal only with specific issues arising in specific cases properly before them. They have no investigatory power, or reporting responsibility, beyond the immediate case.
Even if a case may alert an Adjudicator to possible systemic issues requiring broader investigation of a BCM, there is no one to whom they can refer these concerns for any such follow-up action.
Not even to the Body Corporate Commissioner’s Office. The Body Corporate Commissioner has often reminded the UOAQ that his Office has no investigatory powers regarding the Body Corporate Manager-industry.
But if not the Adjudicators, and not the Commissioner’s Office, then who?
The answer is ‘No one’.
UOAQ’s response: NewsFlash #08 ‘Body Corporate Managers: Let the buyer beware…there is little else to protect you’
The UOAQ issued NewsFlash #08 earlier this year, warning our members about this lack of regulatory oversight of Body Corporate Managers in QLD. The full article can be read here.
The NewsFlash itself was prompted by a reported Adjudication containing quite harsh comments about the professional conduct and integrity of a Sunshine Coast Body Corporate Manager: see Northcliffe  QBCCMCmr 211.
Notwithstanding the authority and significance of the Adjudicator’s comments in that case, the UOAQ’s main focus is on any broader, systemic issues which may emerge from it, or similar cases.
There simply is no investigatory process in place to further investigate the Body Corporate Manager’s reported conduct.
We called on the QLD government to include regulatory oversight of Body Corporate Managers in their current strata law reform process, as a matter of urgency.
So far, there has been no response from the government.
However, the UOAQ did receive numerous calls from our members.
All expressed support for some form of regulatory oversight of Body Corporate Managers, with particular emphasis on:
- Mandatory registration;
- On-going prudential audits of the Body Corporate Managers’ competence and compliance; and
- A formal ‘complaint’ process with real sanctions, including compensation, fines and even de-registration.
One member even alerted us to another Adjudication containing harsh comments about the professional conduct and integrity of a Gold Coast Body Corporate Manager: see Springfields Gold Coast  QBCCMCmr 552.
Q: One-off aberrations, or symptoms of deeper problems? A: Who knows?
The UOAQ had no intention of sparking a ‘That’s not a knife…this is a knife’ competition between Adjudications containing harsh words about Body Corporate Managers. However, the similarities between Northcliffe and Springfields provide interesting reading: very similar issues; very similar comments.
Without leaping to any conclusions about the Body Corporate Managers’ overall conduct, the UOAQ considers it would be reasonable for any owner to ask of both Body Corporate Managers:
- What about their other clients? Is there any process in place to alert them to the Adjudication?
- What about other complexes looking for a new Body Corporate Manager? Is there any process in place to alert them to these Adjudications, other than trawling through all of the reported Adjudications?
- Is there any regulatory agency, like the Body Corporate Commissioner’s Office or even Strata Community Australia (SCA), which can investigate and apply appropriate sanctions if necessary?
The answers, all in the negative, provide little comfort to unit owners in QLD.
We are not alone.
Jimmy Thomson, a NSW columnist, recently published an article calling for the reining in of ‘strata management cowboys’ (his words, not ours) in Time for the cowboys of strata management to be reined in
JimmyT (his professional pseudonym) noted:
“The Fair Trading Office in NSW received 800 inquiries about strata managers, and 48 official complaints, during the past financial year – a rise of 50% on 2014-15…..
Strata management is going through a transition. Increasingly, the best companies are highly professional and look after their clients properly as a means of enhancing their reputation and expanding their businesses.
However, there are still cowboys who don’t know what they’re doing and don’t really care. They operate with the same ethics as cattle rustlers, rounding up the maximum number of clients with the promise of super-cheap rates, knowing that there is no way they can deliver a reasonable service at those prices.
Strata schemes can be cash cows where, often, investors vote for the lowest cost option while the residents – owners and tenants – pay the price in poor service.”
Strong words indeed. Do they apply in QLD? You decide…
One caveat though: Quality of service does not necessarily follow cost. It is our experience that many of the lower-priced Body Corporate Managers provide exemplary service.
Where to from here?
All we can do is call on the QLD government, once again, to demonstrate some real leadership and do something about what seems to be a systemic, and endemic problem in our strata world.
The sooner this issue gets included in the current law reform process, with a High Priority stamp on it, the better it will be for everyone…including the many good Body Corporate Managers in QLD who are being painted with the same brush as their recalcitrant ‘colleagues’.
This post appears in Strata News #118.
Are you interested in more information about Body Corporate Managers QLD or more general strata information particular to Queensland? Visit our FactSheet: Committee Concerns, FactSheet: Strata Managers OR FactSheet: Strata Legislation Queensland
After a free PDF of this article about Body Corporate Managers QLD? Log into your existing LookUpStrata Account to download the printable file. Not a member? Simple – join for free on our Registration page.